C..............C......G....C..E..G etc.
The Harmonic Series continues virtually endlessly, the number of Harmonics doubling in each octave. It was once believed that all "pure" intervals must be based upon relationships between harmonics, and therefore result only from frequency ratios of integer-based fractions, such as "6/5". This method of defining intervals is known as "Just Intonation". However, any tuning system based upon Just Intonation severely restricts the composer, allowing the use of an extremely limited number of keys.
The simplest Pythagorean right-angle triangle has sides with the proportions 3:4:5. As Harmonics, the 3:4:5 ratios produce the Second Inversion of a Major Triad. This is of particular interest, since Pythagoras (as far as we know) conducted the first exploration of Harmonics with his monochord!
If an isosceles right-angled triangle is constructed such that the equal sides forming the right-angle are each "1", the hypotenuse is "sqrt 2". If "1" is regarded as a Fundamental Frequency, the hypotenuse (sqrt 2) is
exactly 6 semitones, or one-half octave lower. (This can be demonstrated by placing 3 nails in a piece of wood, and wrapping them in one string, all segments being of equal tension. Pluck each of the 3 string segments.)
An Experiment In The Perception of Tuning
If the human ear is sensitive to pitch differences as small as 1/20 of a semitone, we must ask how any musician can accept Equal Temperament, with its Major 3rds being stretched by about 1/7 of a semitone, and its Major 6ths by about 1/6 of a semitone. This led to a simple experiment.
On one of our studio pianos a C major triad was tuned to Just Intonation, and on another, to Equal Temperament. More than 50 musicians were asked to compare, and express their preference. Unanimously, they agreed that the Just Intonation tuning sounded "dull and dead", while the Equal Temperament tuning sounded "vibrant and alive". Perhaps more than "accustomization" is involved; one would expect the "natural" to be preferred to the "contrived".
This initiated a search for a possible "natural basis" to Equal Temperament.
The ratio of Harmonics 139:138 almost perfectly coincides with 1/8 of a semitone of Equal Temperament. (The 1/8 semitone was explored by the Mexican composer, Julian Carrillo, in the late 19th century.) In fact, "(139/138) to the 8th power" (1.059463...) almost perfectly coincides with one Equal Tempered semitone (1.059463...). The discrepancy is 0.00000487 semitones per semitone, or 0.00005843 semitones per octave. The accumulated discrepancy over the complete range of a piano is 0.00042362 semitones, and over the entire range of human hearing (about 10 octaves), 0.00058431 semitones.
Remember, the human ear can detect a pitch discrepancy of about 0.05 semitones. Therefore, for all practical purposes, the miniscule discrepancy may be disregarded, and the two systems considered one and the same. We conclude: Equal Temperament, although more complex, is as natural as Just Intonation, since, for all practical purposes, it can be constructed from an integer-based fraction, and therefore from natural harmonic ratios.
The Golden Ratio (Golden Mean) and Music The
"Golden Ratio", or
"Phi" is derived from the Fibonacci Number Series, and is usually expressed as "[(sqrt 5) plus 1] / 2". [The first numbers of the Fibonacci Series (after 0) are 1, 2, 3, 5, and 8. When taken as frequency ratios, they form a beautifully voiced major chord, found, for example, as the final chord of Chopin's "Harp" Etude, Op. 25, No. 1.]
Taken as a frequency ratio, Phi is almost exactly 8.33 semitones above a given musical frequency. Because every third number in the Fibonacci Series is an
even number, the relationship between two consecutive even numbers in the series approaches "Phi cubed" (with rapidly increasing accuracy, as the Number Series is ascended.) When "Phi-cubed" is applied to any given musical frequency, the resultant tone is almost exactly 25 semitones higher, for example, C to C#)
Two Methods of Tuning by the Golden RatioMethod 1:The result of "Phi cubed" (C#) is transposed down two octaves, and again "Phi cubed" is applied, resulting in a D. By continuing to apply the same principle, we can arrive at a 12-tone chromatic scale. While the deviation from normal E.T. semitones is just 0.00729111 semitones per semitone, this accumulates to 0.08749331 semitones per octave, or 0.63443265 semitones per "piano-range", or 0.87493312 semitones per "range of human hearing". Thus, such a tuning system would be practical only for musical instruments of extremely limited range.
Method 2:
In this method, the semitone is
defined by the Golden Ratio. "Phi cubed", instead of being regarded as
almost exactly 25 semitones of conventional Equal Temperament, is seen as
exactly 25 "Golden Semitones". ONE Golden Semitone is therefore defined as the "25th root of Phi-cubed". The discrepancy between one Golden semitone and one conventional semitone of Equal Temperament is 0.00029164 semitones per semitone, accumulating to 0.00349973 semitones per octave; 0.02537306 semitones per "piano range"; 0.03499733 semitones per "range of human hearing". The difference between this method of Golden Ratio Tuning and conventional Equal Temperament rests well beyond detection by the human ear.
For all practical purposes, the miniscule discrepancy may therefore be disregarded, and the two systems considered one and the same.
Next, consider the
cochlea of the inner ear, which distinguishes various pitches. Looking rather like a snail, it is a logarithmic spiral, proportioned according to the Golden Ratio.
In consideration of the relationship of the Golden Ratio to both the semitone and to the cholea, the Golden Ratio may possibly explain our acceptance of intervals based upon the semitones of Equal Temperament.
(Further investigation of the Golden Ratio is strongly recommended.)
If division of the octave into 12 equal parts is natural, perhaps other equal divisions are equally natural. We have experimented with many possibilities, but find a division of 5 equal parts especially appealing. This division is the basis of the Slendro Scale, used in the Gamelan music of Java and Bali. Although tunings of the Slendro scale vary slighly from region to region, each step can essentially be regarded as the "5th root of 2". Although the number 5 is also critical in the definition of Phi, we have not established a direct relationship between Phi and the Slendro scale.
PART 2: Music and the World Around Us
1. The "Primary Colours of Light" possess a frequency ratio of 4:5:6, the same as the the Root Position of a Major Triad.